An Open Letter to the Patrons of the 9:30 Club
This is the second in my highly irregular series of open letters. The first addressed some odd behavior practiced by the men at my gym.
Dear Patrons of the 9:30 Club,
I put up with a lot from you because we have so many shared loves. A love of good music, a love of the U St./Shaw area, a love of $5 gin and tonics. But lately I think you're taking our relationship for granted. I recognize that a standing-room-only concert experience will never be a polite affair, but some behavior I witnessed at the October 13th Yelle show means we have to have a little chat.
No matter how dancey a concert gets, it is NEVER a dance floor. On a dance floor you can move wherever you want, in whatever patterns and directions, without doing a whole lot to disrupt anyone else's experience. At a concert, one thousand people are given a relatively small bit of floor space to watch something on a stage. When you and your stiletto-wearing friend clasp hands and crash sideways through ten people before trampling my feet, you are acting like you're on a dance floor. That's why so many people were yelling at you and "accidentally"
spilling drinks in your hair.
At a concert, you should pretend that there is a little box around you. Its walls are three inches behind, in front and on either side of you. This box extends to the ceiling. That is your dancing box. You can jump up and down in it, you can move your feet in it, you can bop to the left and to the right. But if any part of your body leaves this box you are probably annoying the people around you. For instance: At the Hot Chip show, the guy who leaned back into my chest every time the band sang "Laid back..." left his box. The girl at Of Montreal who waved her hands around like she was being attacked by bees? She left her box. And her ring finger went into my mouth three times. It was disgusting.
(Special note to couples: Even if you are standing together, your box does not get any bigger. If you make out, grind or otherwise simulate intercourse during a show you have probably left your box. And the back/forward pelvis action of your humping motions actually affect the people behind and in front of you. It's a double infraction.)
The choice to dance at a show is a personal one. I will support any dancing that doesn't cause bodily injury to the people around you. However, I myself prefer not to let my body move at shows. I am way too tall and way too gangly. If I move my feet I step on toes and if I raise my arms I obstruct sightlines. This is why I express my joy by bobbing in place and singing along. No one gets hurt. So please, random straight girl, do not spend the first four songs tugging on my arm and manually moving my hips so that I will dance with you. Similarly, don't track down my friends after the show and tell them that you hate me. When I told you to "Leave me alone" it was for good reason.
On the subject of height: Though I am 6'2, I will do everything in my power to make sure the person directly behind me can see. If I say to you "Hey, would you like to stand in front of me" do not call me a jerk. I am actually trying to be considerate. If you choose not to stand in front of me when I offer, do not spend the rest of the show glowering at me or whispering to your companions while pointing at me and making stabbing motions.
Please watch what you say at the show. You, random straight guy, created an uncomfortable situation at the last Hercules and Love Affair concert when you ascertained which of the band's vocalists was a lesbian and then screamed "I'm just glad the smoking hot one isn't a lesbian." No, dude, the smoking hot one is an MTF. And is so far out of your league that you're lucky to be in the same room as her.
If you want a souvenir from your concert experience, you can buy a t-shirt or give the bass player a blowjob (lord knows I've tried.) Do not record the entire show on your camera or cell phone. Because that means I have to watch the entire show through your camera or cell phone. I'm tall, remember? When you hold something up above your head it will usually rest at my eye level. Plus it can be really distracting when the security guard tromps through the audience to kick you out during my favorite song.
Finally, please don't steal my clothes. It creates an awkward moment when I catch you leaving the club in the highly distinctive red, white and blue Adidas jacket that I lost 30 minutes prior. Although I would have enjoyed it when you had to throw out all the used kleenexes in the pockets.
So in summation: You are not in your living room listening to a CD. Please have as much fun as you want to when you go the 9:30 Club. Dance until your uterus drops, or your backwards "Cocks" baseball cap fuses to your skull. But keep in mind that there are a lot of other people around you who are trying to have fun too.
16 comments:
And why do people who stand toward the back think it's OK to talk? Not just make an occasional comment about the band or a song, but an outright conversation about something totally irrelevant to the show. That drives me nuts.
As I vertically challenge person, my experience at the 930 Club has, of the last few times, horrible. People stepping on me,drinks spilled...I remember before it went smoke free, and being burned.
This post... was... phenomenal. --Rios
You forgot about the woo girl, dancing like a stripper at the Peter, Björn and John show, who was dipping her ponytail into your $5 gin and tonic and then whipping you in the face with it.
haha! that is all.
I agree with you 95%. I think it is appropriate to consider certain concerts "dance concerts." At these concerts those wishing to dance should use polite measures to move to the front of the crowd where they can then interact among similar fans in a more rambunctious way (dancing out side their box, but within a collectively larger box). If you plan on attending one of these "dance concerts" and plan on not getting your box invaded, then you should either move to the back of the floor or to the upper level. For example... if you think you are going to stand close to the stage in your own un-intruded box for Gogol Bordello, then you are just living a fantasy. I have been to many many concerts and I think the last thing we can complain about here is too many people dancing. But to reiterate, I agree with you in all other respects... in addition to remaining in your own personal box, I would like to add that things happening in your box should be refrained to something you wouldn't mind watching the ugliest person in the venue doing right in front of you with no way for you to not watch.
That kind of crowd is why I normally don't go to concerts.
Also, certain bands get better crowds. I went to see Cowboy Junkies at 9:30 a few years back and had an amazing time. The crowd was cool, very copacetic and mixed in age. Not everyone there was a spoiled angry white girl acting out. A few years before that I saw Saint Etienne at Bowery Ballroom (nyc) and the crowd was the same: very cool.
All of that being said I agree with Zach. The 9:30 Club is not your living room. Grow up.
A few bad dancing eggs are not reason enough to suggest draconian space ethics. For every obnoxious dancer, there are ten more agile movers keeping to themselves while moving at the same time. For a blog that talks a big talk about inclusion, this rant/comment thread reeks of class warfare and re-masculinizing indie space post-riot grrl and like my girl emma said, there will be dancing in my revolution.
Something that has always brought me great angst is the infamous mid-concert bathroom trip. I'm always torn between doing serious harm to my bladder or awkwardly crashing my way through several hundred people. The trip out usually goes well enough, but the effort to get back to your pod of friends in the middle of the concert floor requires a level of tact and maneuverability that alludes me.
I think the bigger issue here is self-segregation or maybe awareness of your surroundings.
People who stand in the back and dance like a dervish are being inappropriate, as are people who stand up in the front and get annoyed that they're surrounded by a mosh pit.
The secret is to figure how how well your desired behavior jives with that of those around you. If they're out of sync, either change your expectations or move to a section where other like-minded folks are located.
Draconian space ethics? Class warfare? Aren't you exaggerating just a little bit? What the author is talking about is common courtesy.
Having a great time at the expense of everyone else's great time is discourteous. Period.
Anonymous with the small bladder: I here you. I usually force myself to go before the concert, even if that means standing at the urinal for ten minutes while pressing on my lower stomach.
to be honest, i don't like the box idea very much. part of the reason why dc crowds at shows are so bad is because people just stand there with their arms folded across their chests, looking as unimpressed as possible. i think how much you move out of your "box" is more dependent on how crowded the show is and how much physical contact you create with other people. i think movement should be encouraged more rather than less, so long as you're not interrupting the enjoyment of other people. in a packed show, less movement out of your box would be better.
Sounds like you should trade your nights at 9:30 for nights at the symphony. There you can be as quiet and antisocial as you please.
I just went back and read your post about the gym, and I'm thinking, since you have so much trouble with public spaces and proximity to other people, maybe it's not the 9:30 Club or the gym that's the problem. How do you feel about grocery stores? airports?
re: Steven
I hate most people because they are remarkably stupid, they make life increasingly difficult for everyone who isn't stupid. Look around. We live in the only country on earth that put George W. Bush into office twice. Crumbling economy? They want i-pods and Prada sneakers, they'll be happy. Mortgages and gas too expensive? They want Dancing with the Stars and Beyonce.
Although a misanthrope I am not afraid to go outside, attend concerts, shop and join friends in restaurants. I do not avoid train stations, airports, gyms and supermarkets. I suffer through them instead.
Mediocrity is very hot commodity in our capitalist democracy.
This really reminds me of a post from Stuff White People Like:
http://stuffwhitepeoplelike.com/2008/02/17/68-standing-still-at-concerts/
As far as concerts go, I'm definitely a dancer, although I try my hardest to be respectful of other people. The only reason I may end up dancing in the back is if I'm with a friend who doesn't want to dance. It sucks leaving a friend standing alone, so I compromise.
On the other hand, if I've established a (small) dancing space with my neighbors, it's really rude if you move into it and then get upset at me for moving around. If you see someone dancing and you want to be undisturbed, don't assume that the half-foot around her is a vacant spot just waiting for you to squeeze in... or that she wants you to come up and "hit on" her by standing way too close and "accidentally" rubbing up against her. I don't care if you're male or female, it's obnoxious and creepy.
Post a Comment