Tuesday, July 08, 2008

A Taboo Topic (?): LGBT Kids

Earlier this week, I was on a plane back from Ohio when I noticed a young girl across the aisle from me. The girl, who must have been no older than 12, caught my attention because, by her wardrobe and demeanor, she was the doppleganger of my Midwestern youth. Skater sneakers – check. Slightly baggy flares – check. Sports bag as purse – check. Too-cool-for-school slouch and unkempt hair that matches that message – check. I felt bad for staring since she was traveling alone and probably a little on-edge already, but it was so surreal to look at what was practically a mirror image of a young me that I couldn’t help but intermittently look over to see what she was up to. Part of me wanted to offer to be her mentor – “Hey,” I wanted to say, “I’m pretty sure you’re me twelve years ago. Here’s my email – contact me if you ever need advice about life.” However, that would have been - by all cultural standards – creepy; so, I kept to myself and reflected on my own youth as I wondered who she was so frequently texting, or trying to text, throughout the entire flight.

As I flipped back and forth between distant memories of myself and the reality of the look-alike sitting near me, I realized another caveat to our similarities: the girl sitting across from me was almost certainly gay. Other people looking at her might argue that she’s simply a tomboy or a fashionably apathetic or homely young girl; however, this girl was as gay as I was when I was twelve, and I wondered whether or not she knew, or had contemplated, it. I surely hadn't when I was twelve; according to society, and, thus, me, I was a tomboy. I acted the way I did and had the demeanor that I had simply because I liked to play sports. To me, that made perfect sense, so I never had to question my sexuality. I was a girl, and I liked boys.

Today, my one distinct and solitary memory of being young and gay is from fifth grade when I looked at my school’s band director and thought, “God, if I was a boy, I’d want to marry a woman just like that”; however, I quickly dismissed that thought as irrational and psychologically inappropriate. In fact, throughout the rest of middle school and most of high school, I never even contemplated the idea that I might be gay; it quite literally wasn’t an option. I didn’t have exposure to any real life gays, never mind real life lesbians. Plus, I aspired so much for a future in politics that I learned a lesson from the Clinton era and refused to do anything that might one-day be considered, according to a naïve teen, “dirt” – I never smoked, drank, nor got anything less than an A on a report card. I’m pretty sure that somewhere in my subconscious I also came to the firm conclusion that being gay was high-selling dirt.

Given my straight and narrow take on life, I bumbled through my teen years thinking the women I would intermittently obsess over, whether they were celebrities, teachers, or soccer coaches, were women that I just really wanted to be like. I wanted to sing like Alanis Morissette. I wanted hair like Natalie Imbruglia. I wanted to be rich like my sixth grade teacher. Furthermore, not only did I completely ignore my draw to these women and their beautiful jaw lines, but I also had crushes on boys. Sure, they were always the All-American boys that all the girls had crushes on, but the important thing was that I liked them, too. And this is essentially what my youth boiled down to: seemingly inexplicable obsessions with women in my life, and generic crushes on boys with nice tans and finely gelled crew cuts.

As many gays do, now that I’m grown up and gay, I feel somewhat cheated out of my teen years. I have irrational thoughts that maybe I wouldn’t be so awkward now if I had been able to appropriately release all those awkward energies during my teen years. Moreover, part of me is simply annoyed at the adults in my life – didn’t they realize I was gay? I was young and didn’t know my ass from my elbow about anything sexual, but surely some of the adults in my life must have realized that my boy crushes were feigned and strained, right? These questions inevitably bring up a whole slew of other questions: Why is it so taboo to assume that someone is gay (“I don’t want to offend you, but are you gay?”)? Why do we – adults – continuously treat children who we know are gay like they are straight? The last question is one that has bothered me for a long time and that I honestly have no idea how to answer: How can we reach out to young gays and help them come to terms their sexuality pre-freshman year of college when so many adults turn a blind eye to their sexualities?

As much as I hate it, I know that I am one of those adults who doesn’t really do anything to help. Many of us are. Most of us have met kids and thought, “I wonder if his/her parents are thinking what I'm thinking.” Few of us, however, have looked over at the parents and asked, “So, are you making any special accommodations for your child’s very likely homosexuality?” God forbid. That would make us rude, presumptuous, and probably a sexual predator. However, part of me wishes someone had seen me when I was young and given my parents a heads up that there was a good chance that I wasn't just a tomboy. My life wouldn’t have been drastically different, but if my parents had considered the possiblity, maybe they could have exposed me to more gay stuff. Maybe if I had known that some real – and normal - people really are gay, then I wouldn’t have had to think it was so irrational and inappropriate to dream of marrying my school’s band director.

One of my hopes today is that, as a society, we find an answer to the question of how we can appropriately reach out to young gays. In a majority straight world, where gay kids aren’t born to parents with the same minority status, I hope that our culture can one-day act mature enough to send the message to kids that gay is, in fact, a normal state of being. However, part of me is really pessimistic about this. Why do commercials and other mainstream advertisements still only show straight couples? Why are movies with gay protagonists generally considered straight-to-indie-theater flicks? Why do we need separate TV channels to air programs that revolve around gay characters?

Basically, I think that grown-up gays have a lot of responsibility to make this a more gay-friendly country for future gay generations. Gay kids don’t get to share the burden of their sexual orientation with likewise families. Nor do they get to go to enclaves, whether they be churches or other local hang-outs, where they are free to be proud of who they are. Grown-up gays, however, have done it; whether your parents continuously offered support, lived in denial, or kicked you out of the house, if you’re reading this you made it through. Furthermore, most of us still know what it’s like to feel isolated and uncomfortable at times; so, instead of basking in the glory of making it out of middle and high school, why aren’t we more proactive about reaching out to the upcoming generations in need of our support? I’m challenging myself to become more involved in making this a more welcoming and safer country for young gays, and I’m urging others to do the same.

This post was inspired by the opening of the Wanda Alston House, the new center for homeless LGBT youth, which Tyrone mentioned in his earlier post. The opening happens tonight from 4:30pm-8:30pm at 804 46th ST, NE.

14 comments:

meichler said...

Great post, Stephanie. I often wonder how we might be able to better support queer youth and give them a solid foundation... Perhaps you should have slipped a TNG card in her sports-bag-as-purse.

Greg Fletcher-Marzullo said...

These are tough questions. In our apartment complex, a kid in his teens rode by me on his bike and gave me a look that was clearly one of recognition.

He stopped and asked me about our, admittedly bizarre-looking, dog. Then he went into how he really wanted to find a boyfriend.

My hubby and I have befriended him, but I can't say I haven't felt a little paranoid about the whole thing. What if people see or gossip or suspect that we're luring him into a life of sexual debauchery? After all, isn't that what straight people think we do?

While being aware that this is all a possibility, I've consciously tried to make other choices, ones that would hopefully plant some seeds in his burgeoning gay consciousness of what it's like to be out, proud and making through life much as others would.

I feel angry when I think about how homophobia (and its progenitor, patriarchy) have robbed our gay kids of connections to gay adults, and how this has robbed gay adults of nurturing our the next gay generation.

Jenny Miller said...

I struggled with this when I worked at an elementary school. The kids who really identified with me, followed me around, etc., were obviously gay, but I didn't feel like I could do anything to help them. Usually I just had to keep them from hugging on me and sitting on my lap, because I've got that gay paranoia thing Greg mentioned.

Anonymous said...

Now that I'm a school librarian instead of a classroom teacher, I'm a bit more removed from this particular issue since I don't have as close and constant a relationship with the students I work with. But when I was in the classroom, I had to strike a balance between openness (creating a positive environment for discussion of all topics; sponsoring the school's gay-straight alliance; calling out homophobia when I saw it) and a recloseting that was stark in its completeness. I went out of my way never to talk about my personal life because I didn't want to freak out some of the teenage boys I worked with and cause them to be hesitant to come to me for help with their writing and their other classwork. For certain students, knowing that I was gay would have shut down necessary teacher-student communication.

Except in a specialized situation like that, though, I'd encourage as much openness as possible. There's probably no way to connect with a baby-dyke on a plane in any meaningful way because of the fleetingness of the contact, but the type of mentoring interaction that Greg mentions in his comment is healthy for all involved. Kids need guidance, and it's not like most heterosexual parents can provide it for their gay and lesbian children.

Homophobia is not, however, the only reason for the lack of gay adult-gay kid relationships. I'd get into the history of the gay community's interactions with its boy-love (and girl-love) contingent, but that's a whole separate post and I don't want to muddy the waters too much here.

Anonymous said...

I am a 15 year old obviously lesbian kid. I've lived in the city all my life, and its never been a big deal at all. The only thing I wish I had was a way to meet other queer youth. Its pretty hard to find other kids my age who know their gay, and its frustrating because I know their out there.

maggie said...

I work for an incredibly liberal, albeit private, school where a number of assemblies, forums, and guest speakers (Kevin Jennings & openly gay alumni) during the 2007-08 school year revolved around LGBT issues. At one particular forum for students, parents, and faculty, a number of students at the table where I happen to be sitting (one of whom was openly gay) mentioned that us "older" folks need to stop pulling them out of the closet & shoving rainbows in their faces. (!)

Now, I'm not sure if they mean stop holding assemblies & discussions (made possible by the $28K/yr tuition, $1.6mil annual fund figures, and other such figures) or if they're just teenagers frustrated with anything and everything adults say.

But what I do know is that these assemblies, discussions, and forums help identify people (openly gay faculty, alumni, and parents -- that's right, we've got a divorced AND remarried lesbian couple, yeah 4 moms) who may be possible mentors for these students who are LGBT, and sometimes more importantly "Questioning."

And now I'll plug The New Gay: this site is also incredibly important. I went out of my way to let one particular senior know about TNG (he went out of his way to say thanks), and how great is it that the above post is from a 15 year old lesbian reader?

If anything, we can be an image of what LGBTQ life can be like, should be like, was like, and is like.

Lord knows I could've used an image or two in my days.

Anonymous said...

I would say the three best things to do are

- Ask whether the youth has a girlfriend or boyfriend from the get go. Being nonchalant about it allows all youth, gay or straight, see that is being affirmative.

- Volunteer with youth organizations. DC has Sexual Minority Youth Assistance League (SMYAL) - http://www.smyal.org/

- Be a role model. Show kids that being queer does not have to mean fitting in a cookie-cutter stereotype.

I personally can say I have done all three. I tutor straight male teen. He was a little distant when I first introduced him to my boyfriend, but he went back to our normal routine after awhile. He just needed time to register that I was still me I just dated guys instead of girls.

~ Supportive Queer Adult without the Creepy Vibe

Anonymous said...

Another comment is that individuals during their youth and teenage years need to discuss who they are themselves. Gay or straight? Being in a straight-majority doesn't help, but sometimes, people have to discover things for themselves.

~ Supportive Queer Adult without the Creepy Vibe

Linsey said...

I know for me it comes back to role models. And as I typically don't see myself as the type of person Fathers and Mothers hope their children grow up to be, I believe being out and content with who you are as a queer individual helps these questioning youths in the long run.

I am out and proud (as cliche as that may sound).

I had a teacher back in middle school who was obviously a lesbian (and the only lesbian I knew for a very long time). I always wonder if this nerdy science teacher were a bit more comfortable with herself, or if I would have had more positive queer role models around to look up to that maybe my self loathing and hatred of myself wouldn't have been so painful. Hell- I might have even been able to come out in high school.

Anyone have former queer teachers they were able to relate to?

Anonymous said...

I read TNG periodically, as articles come through my RSS reader. One recommendation - the byline at the top of the article would be helpful (vs. at the bottom).

I'm glad someone mentioned SMYAL - I don't know them personally, but hear good things about them.

I was at a Bat Mitzvah a number of years ago. The only children that were invited were female friends of the Bat Mitvah girl, and a few children of family/friends. They had karaoke. The girls had a lot of fun along with an ~8 year old boy. He sang the lead for a couple of songs with 2 girls doing backup. He knew the songs, sang the lead well, sang louder to get the girls back on track. I asked the hostess about him - she said his parents bought him a lot of trucks - but he liked making sets to put dolls into. I didn't really know what to say - but hoped that the parents would be accepting - the hostess agreed.

Anonymous said...

I am a gay 16 year old guy, and I honestly wish someone had done this for me when I was younger. I struggled with my sexuality for a while before coming to terms with it, and some kind of gay mentor or something would have been great.

Now that I am comfortable with my sexuality (and out), whenever I see a younger kid who is obviously gay, I feel like I have to go out of my way to befriend them and be nice to them. I think maybe, seeing as how I am still a teenager, this would be seen as a lot less creepy, and less weird for the other kid involved.

Side note: I just found this blog, and love it.

Anonymous said...

Download Mal Waldron Mp3 (5) http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist460380/michel-sajrawy/1/ - Michel Sajrawy (1) [url=http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist303566/benny-goodman-with-helen-forrest/1/]Benny Goodman with Helen Forrest[/url] (1) http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist413025/marc-copland/1/ - Marc Copland (1) Al Di Meola and Leonid Agutin (1) [url=http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist304098/garage-a-trois/1/]Garage A Trois[/url] (2) http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist229142/riotgun-bullet-treatment/1/ - Riotgun - Bullet Treatment (1) Grupo Batuque (2) http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist347064/franco-cerri-enrico-intra/1/ - Franco Cerri & Enrico Intra (1) [url=http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist342220/sheila-jordan-and-e-s-p-trio/1/]Sheila Jordan and E.S.P. Trio[/url] (1) [url=http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist248308/abbey-lincoln-and-archie-shepp/1/]Abbey Lincoln and Archie Shepp[/url] (1) [url=http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist175151/simone/1/]Simone[/url] (8) [url=http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist495464/nick-colionne/1/]Nick Colionne[/url] (3) http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist237353/joe-lovano-nonet/1/ - Joe Lovano Nonet (1) http://femalejazzvocal.com/artist339434/martial-solal-and-didier-lockwoo/1/ - Martial Solal and Didier Lockwoo (1) Kenny Burrell Jimmy Raney (1)

Anonymous said...

Leaglizing Street Drugs

http://www.realintheday.com/ - cialis kaufen
Somit ist Cialis fur eine Behandlung der erektilen Dysfunktion ideal.
[url=http://www.realintheday.com/]cialis kaufen[/url]

Anonymous said...

Creating and selling computer games is for the time being a worthwhile business. It requisite be able to do it. Individuals get no conceivably of it to wear out in to fight with the colossal companies enmeshed with in making games. More and more teenagers and regular children's passion for the purpose games. We requirement therefore look such that they literally determine spellbinding to beat the market. And to dream up justified such a tournament [url=http://www.allp2ptv.org/forum/profile.php?section=personality&id=61006]gry[/url] oraz [url=http://www.bookmark-favoriten.com/tag/gry/]darmowe gry [/url]
need to be a gargantuan fiscal outlay. Today the supermarket is huge competition. Computer games force to be really high calibre, riveting, engaging. That also was the plot Devil May Cry. It was published in 2001, but commission on it actually lasted distinct months. Producers wanted to fine-tune monotonous the smallest details of Old harry May Cry. They succeeded in this. Rake May Note scheme did a important sensation. We are cock-a-hoop to be bought for scads months. Players from bated puff passed consequent after stages of the sport, the next mission - which has not again been easy. It is rare that this was reasonable a game - ideal from start to end.