Tuesday, July 01, 2008

A Black Snowflake

Alfonso Ribeiro as Carlton Banks, the preppy "snowflake" featured on Fresh Prince of Bel-Air.
This post was submitted by Tyrone Hanley.The other day a white friend called me a "snowflake." It was not the first time someone accused me of "acting white."

Once I called my grandparents, and my grandfather, whom I had not spoken to in a long time, was shocked to hear that the voice on the other end was his grandson. He said I sounded like a white boy. Sometimes when I tell people that I have a boyfriend, they ask me if he is white. I usually ask them why they ask, and the response has always been that I seem like I would date white guys. My boyfriend is actually white and so was my last and only other boyfriend. A part of me feels shame, because I have met their assumption of me, and I know that I have and continue to battle with internalized racism.

Another part of me is infuriated. I wonder what they think I am supposed to act like as a black person. Do they feel that aspects of me are artificial? How does one "act white?" How does one "act black?" My only answer is stereotypes. I do not know of a measuring device that determines the authenticity of one's blackness or whiteness. I am very well aware that race is a construct that was created by society through law, policies, and culture throughout history. Race is not a biological reality.

Nevertheless, I understand that we give race so much meaning that it impacts all of us on a very deep level. For me, I have struggled all of my life with this reality. As a boy, I wanted to be a white, blue-eyed girl. I knew that white was better than black and my interests and behaviors were only okay for girls in society's eyes. I felt the pressure of being the only black kid in my honor's English class. If I said the wrong thing, my entire race would be put down. My interactions with the gay black scene in DC and elsewhere in the country have left me with the feeling that I am viewed as a "white gay." In the midst of all of this, where am I to stand? I have decided to stand with diversity.

I feel most at home in diverse settings. In these spaces, I find less of a need to confirm to any one particular standard. This is why I am in love with big cosmopolitan cities, and I seek out bars and clubs with all sorts of people. My friends are Black, White, Latino, Asian, college graduates, non-college graduates, older, younger, etc. When you see me with my friends, we look like we were ripped out of a United Colors of Benetton ad. This is the world I try to surround myself in for the survival of the real me. Otherwise, I may just be swallowed up by others' expectations of me.

Our social identities can be a source of empowerment in relating to others like ourselves. However, they can also constrict us to limited versions of ourselves. I believe that the civil and human rights struggles are about just laws and an equal society and the freedom to define who we are for ourselves -- to actualize our full humanity.

My road to self-acceptance is a part of this continuing fight.If being who I want to be means that some may think I am being fake, then let it be. I know that this is no act. This is me.

6 comments:

Ben said...

Tyrone, I love your writing, send more.

Also, I can empathize in a sense. When I go home to Louisiana, I get the same treatment regarding the way I talk now, the way I dress, the ideas I hold, and even the food I cook. In some ways I'm left feeling that I'm not "cajun" enough, but when I take a step back, what I sense is that people identify themselves so much by their immediate environment that they aren't really saying I'm not good enough, they're saying that I'm so different from what they know, and because of this they don't quite know how to relate to me. Hopefully the same is true for you.

Anonymous said...

Nice article--I've been in the same boat. Battling homophobic black people or racist gay people, when you just want to be you...

Black "authencity" and homophobia also go hand in hand. Just a dip into oeuvre of Eldrigde Cleaver or any of the nationalists confirms it--and that effect is felt today. Your piece has got me thinking about these issues....

Daniel said...

I believe I can empathize, in a way. I come from a different community, latino, and I do feel out of place when hanging out with other latinos, and funny enough, even more so if they are gay. I've def gotten the 'not latino enough' jokes, and it's an odd situation.

A great majority of my friends are white, my bf is asian, but I think I have perhaps only two latino friends. I don't think I harbor a secret desire to be white, but I don't have an interest to fit into their narrow paradigm of what a latino guy, whether gay or straight, is supposed to look or act like.

natty Boom said...

thanks tyrone! i definitely was not expecting an open dialogue dealing with internalized racism and the lot, but this is a pleasant surprise.

as another black queer, i am often reminded in the gay black scene that "one of these things is not like the others." when i'm hanging in an alternative gay scene, i'm often one of few peeps of color. what's a boi to do? i'm tired of being asked "can i touch your hair" (well, the nice ones ask first) and a myriad of other questions, but there are only a handful of places/events that are as diverse and welcoming as the utopic castle i envision.

lastly, ethereal-lad, i think it's important to think outside of black "authenticity" (very well put) and homophobia. i happen to feel blacks are not really more or less homophobic than whites, latinos, asians, filipinos, etc. people and cultures, however, that have been marginalized and misrepresented tend to react differently to issues. sure outspoken black leaders like eldridge cleaver and even public enemy have spewed a lot of homophobic shit, but so have countless other leaders of many many cultures, races, and ethinicities.

Anonymous said...

Rock. On. with the Carlton Banks photo!

Cambel said...

Hi Tyrone, It can be the same way in other non-racial situations. My ex was from a very blue collar background, he paid for college himself moved to a large city, when he would go back they would accuse him of thinking he was better, of acting stuck up etc... the fact of the matter was, it was their own insecurities coming out. Any of his former friends would have killed to have his life, income etc... and since they didn't the only thing they could do was try to attack him for it. Keep your chin up.