You Dropped the Bomb on Me
The picture on the right is of my nephew. He's a sweet kid who loves his uncle Ben. Pretty good boxer, too. He's stationed at a base in Washington state after recently completing Army training.
Before he drops that bomb on a lot of poor brown people, there are a few very basic things I want him to know about them, and the region in general. Not that it matters to most Americans, but I think he should at least know the basics of who his country is asking him to wage war against.
Source: dmiessler
1. Arabs are part of an ethnic group, not a religion. Arabs were around long before Islam, and there have been (and still are) Arab Christians and Arab Jews. In general, you’re an Arab if you 1) are of Arab descent (blood), or 2) speak the main Arab language (Arabic).
2. Not all Arabs are Muslim. There are significant populations of Arab Christians throughout the world, including in Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Northern Africa and Palestine/Israel.
3. Islam is a religion. A Muslim (roughly pronounced MOOSE-lihm) is someone who follows the religion. So you wouldn’t say someone follows Muslim or is an Islam, just as you wouldn’t say someone follows Christian or is a Christianity.
4. Shia Muslims are similar to Roman Catholics in Christianity. They have a strong clerical presence via Imams and promote the idea of going through them to practice the religion correctly. Sunni Muslims are more like Protestant Christians. They don’t really focus on Imams and believe in maintaining a more direct line to God than the Shia.
5. People from Iran are also known as Persians, and they are not Arabs.
6. Arabs are Semites. We’ve all heard the term anti-Semitism being used — often to describe Arabs. While antisemitism does specifically indicate hatred for Jews, the word “Semite” comes from the Bible and referred originally to anyone who spoke one of the Semitic Languages.
7. According to the Bible, Jews and Arabs are related [Genesis 25]. Jews descended from Abraham’s son Isaac, and Arabs descended from Abraham’s son Ishmael. So not only are both groups Semitic, but they’re also family.
8. Sunni Muslims make up most of the Muslim world (roughly 90%).
9. The country with the world’s largest Muslim population is Indonesia.
10. The rift between the Shia and Sunni started right after Muhammad’s death and originally reduced to a power struggle regarding who was going to become the authoritative group for continuing the faith.
The Shia believed Muhammad’s second cousin Ali should have taken over (the family/cleric model). The Sunni believed that the best person for the job should be chosen by the followers (the merit model) and that’s how the first Caliph, Abu Bakr, was appointed.
Although the conflict began as a political struggle it now mostly considered a religious and class conflict, with political conflict emanating from those rifts.
Sunni vs. Shia | Arab vs. Non-Arab
Here’s how the various Middle Eastern countries break down in terms of Sunni vs. Shia and whether or not they are predominantly Arab. Keep in mind that these are generalizations; significant diversity exists in many of the countries listed.
7 comments:
So, there is a post submitted about how being marginalized by the mainstream community because of race, and then we get what is supposed to be a touching post about dropping bombs on brown people.
Clearly, the New Gay is some what, not to smart or willing to think.
anonymous, congratulations on making no sense at all. If you're going to comment, at least TRY to rub two brain cells together first. If there's a cogent thought hidden somewhere in your comment, try to find it first before you inflict senseless words on other readers.
Given Ben's past comments on domestic U.S. politics and int'l geopolitics, I think it is fair to assume that Ben's comment on "dropping bombs on brown people" was meant to be ironic rather than literal.
More mildly sarcastic than ironic, I think. Neither comes across very well via the written word. I'm not sure what that guy is trying to say. I didn't even read that piece he was referring to until it was posted. I'm curious about his point, whatever it is, and I encourage him to try again. However, I've mostly given up trying to figure out what people think they read. Meh, Contraversy is good for business.
i don't think sarcasm is THAT difficult to get across (i read it loud and clear) it's just that a lot of readers seem to be so dismayingly self-serious that they wouldn't catch a joke if it smacked them across the face with a rubber chicken. and i'm not talking about you parker.
regardless of whether or not sarcasm is easy to 'read" online, personally i want to hear what anonymous #1 has say. race, class, and national identity are difficult subjects. anonymous' comment begs for questions. and frankly, like runnyrabbit commented under the gentrification post above, it's good to have folks on here discuss these questions.
This post strikes me as analogous to trying to learn Latin by picking up the phrases that have slipped into our culture.
I guess a little knowledge is better than none or is it more dangerous?
Post a Comment